Abstract
Purpose
To determine how well the orthopaedic sports medicine literature reported sex‐specific analysis (SSA) in 2011 and 2016.
Methods
The 3 highest‐impact orthopaedic sports medicine subspecialty journals (
American Journal of Sports Medicine
;
Arthroscopy
; and
Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology
,
Arthroscopy
) were selected for review. Two independent investigators reviewed all journal issues published during 2 different calendar years (2011 and 2016). All randomized controlled, prospective and retrospective group, and case–control studies were included. Studies were stratified into those that involved SSA, where sex was a variable in a multifactorial statistical model, and those that only reported sex as a demographic characteristic or used sex‐matched groups without further analysis.
Results
A total of 960 studies evaluating 3,400,569 patients met criteria and were included in this review. Although 44.4% of the overall study population was female, only 293 (30.5%) studies included patient sex as variable in a multifactorial statistical model. The proportion of studies that performed SSA did not differ between 2011 (29.6%) and 2016 (31.1%;
P
= .607), although publications from
American Journal of Sports Medicine
were likely to report SSA (
P
Conclusions
Although most sports medicine studies include approximately 50% female and 50% male patients, statistical analysis differentiating the 2 subsets is not routinely performed. Only 30.5% of all studies performed SSA, 31% of which reported a statistically significant difference in the data when comparing outcomes between male and female patients with the same treatment modalities.
Clinical Relevance
The current study demonstrates that the orthopaedic sports medicine subspecialty literature is lacking in reporting SSA, and that there has been minimal improvement over a 5‐year time period. In addition, this study highlights the high percentage of significant findings within the studies that performed SSA and underscores the differences in sex‐specific injury patterns and treatment outcomes.