Abstract
Abstract
Background
The nasogastric tube (NGT) is recommended routinely by current guidelines in the non-operative management of adhesional small bowel obstruction (ASBO). However, several retrospective studies have reported poorer outcomes in ASBO patients managed with an NGT. We sought to examine current practices among Australian General Surgeons in managing ASBO and using NGTs, assess the presence of surgical equipoise for a potential randomised controlled trial (RCT), and evaluate interest in multi-centre collaboration.
Methods
In October 2021, we conducted an online survey of all active members of General Surgeons Australia using a REDCap
®
questionnaire distributed via email. The survey included clinical scenarios of small bowel obstruction and questions on demographics, management practices, and clinical reasoning. Descriptive statistics were used to summarise all relevant variables.
Results
Of the 893 emails sent, 181 responses were received (20%). Most respondents were from New South Wales (47%) and had subspecialty training (71%). An NGT was used in over 90% of ASBO cases by 42% of respondents. 64% believed NGT use could prevent surgery, and 93% viewed it as having a therapeutic role. Vomiting was the most common indication for insertion, and 69% believed it reduces aspiration risk. Gastrografin
®
was used by 96% of surgeons. 42% expressed willingness to participate in an RCT evaluating NGT use.
Conclusions
There is considerable variation among surgeons in their beliefs regarding its utility. The observed variation in practice patterns and underlying beliefs reflects ongoing clinical uncertainty. Given the exploratory nature of the survey and its response rate, these findings should be interpreted as reflecting practice variability, rather than establishing consensus, and may inform the design of further investigation through a RCT.