InsectChange: Comment

Laurence Gaume; Marion Desquilbet

doi:10.24072/pcjournal.469

InsectChange: Comment | ResearchHub

The InsectChange database (van Klink et al. 2021) underlying the meta-analysis by van Klink et al. (2020a) compiles worldwide time series of the abundance and biomass of invertebrates reported as insects and arachnids, as well as ecological data likely to have influenced the observed trends. On the basis of a comprehensive review of the original studies, we highlight numerous issues in this database, such as errors in insect counts, sampling biases, inclusion of noninsects driving assemblage trends, omission of drivers investigated in original studies and inaccurate assessment of local cropland cover. We show that in more than half of the original studies, the factors investigated were experimentally manipulated or were strong -often not natural- disturbances. These internal drivers created situations more frequently favouring an increase than a decrease in insects and were unlikely to be representative of habitat conditions worldwide. We demonstrate that when both groups were available in original freshwater studies, selecting all invertebrates rather than only insects led to an overestimation of the “insect” trend. We argue that the disparate and non-standardised units of measurement of insect density among studies may have detrimental consequences for users, as was the case for van Klink et al. (2020a, 2022) who log 10 (x+1)-transformed these heterogeneous data, compromising the comparison of temporal trends between datasets and the estimation of the overall trend. We show that geographical coordinates assigned by InsectChange to insect sampling areas are inadequate for the analysis of the local influence of agriculture, urbanisation and climate on insect change for 68% of the datasets. In terrestrial data, the local cropland cover is strongly overestimated, which may incorrectly dismiss agriculture as a driving force behind the decline in insects. Therefore, in its current state, this database enables the study of neither the temporal trends of insects worldwide nor their drivers. The supplementary information accompanying our paper presents in detail each problem identified and makes numerous suggestions that can be used as a basis for improvement.

External reference records

Landscapes and Riverscapes: The Influence of Land Use on Stream Ecosystems

10.1146/annurev.ecolsys.35.120202.110122 · 2004

Is Local Biodiversity Declining or Not? A Summary of the Debate over Analysis of Species Richness Time Trends

10.1016/j.biocon.2017.12.021 · 2018

Scientists' Warning to Humanity on Insect Extinctions

10.1016/j.biocon.2020.108426 · 2020

Comment on "Meta-analysis Reveals Declines in Terrestrial but Increases in Freshwater Insect Abundances"

10.1126/science.abd8947 · 2020

Ecology: Laboratory, Field and Natural Experiments

10.1038/304586a0 · 1983

Interpreting Insect Declines: Seven Challenges and a Way Forward

10.1111/icad.12408 · 2020

BioTIME: A Database of Biodiversity Time Series for the Anthropocene

10.1111/geb.12729 · 2018

Controversy over the Decline of Arthropods: A Matter of Temporal Baseline?

10.24072/pcjournal.131 · 2022

Unresolved referenced work

2017

The Importance of Data-Selection Criteria: Meta-analyses of Stream Predation Experiments

10.2307/177060 · 1999

Flushing Away the Future: The Effects of Wastewater Treatment Plants on Aquatic Invertebrates

10.1016/j.watres.2023.120388 · 2023

Supplementary Information Supporting the 2024 Comment by Laurence Gaume and Marion Desquilbet on the 2021 InsectChange Data Paper Published in Ecology by van Klink et Al.

10.6084/m9.figshare.23458877.v1 · 2024

Estimating Local Biodiversity Change: A Critique of Papers Claiming No Net Loss of Local Diversity

10.1890/15-1759.1 · 2016

10.5281/zenodo.3831673

10.5281/zenodo.3831673 · 2019

Bias and Information in Biological Records

10.1111/bij.12532 · 2015

Revisiting Global Trends in Freshwater Insect Biodiversity

10.1002/wat2.1506 · 2021

Insects Decline on Land, Fare Better in Water, Study Finds

2020

10.1515/9781400846184

10.1515/9781400846184 · 2013

Comparison of Country-Level Cropland Areas between ESA-CCI Land Cover Maps and FAOSTAT Data

10.1080/01431161.2018.1465613 · 2018

Why We Need to Clean the Augean Stables of Ecology – the Case of InsectChange

10.24072/pci.ecology.100641 · 2024

Nature Crisis: 'Insect Apocalypse' More Complicated than Thought

2020

Agriculture and Climate Change Are Reshaping Insect Biodiversity Worldwide

10.1038/s41586-022-04644-x · 2022

Sensitivity of Land Use Change Emission Estimates to Historical Land Use and Land Cover Mapping

10.1002/2015gb005360 · 2017

The Global Population Dynamics Database

10.5063/f1bz63z8 · 2010

Unresolved referenced work

2024

Chironomidae and Oligochaeta for Water Quality Evaluation in an Urban River in Southeastern Brazil

10.1007/s10661-014-3965-5 · 2014

Ups and Downs in Pollinator Populations: When Is There a Decline?

10.5751/es-00255-050102 · 2001

InsectChange: A Global Database of Temporal Changes in Insect and Arachnid Assemblages

10.1002/ecy.3354 · 2021

Long-Term Abundance Trends of Insect Taxa Are Only Weakly Correlated

10.1098/rsbl.2021.0554 · 2022

Erratum for the Report “Meta-Analysis Reveals Declines in Terrestrial but Increases in Freshwater Insect Abundances” by R. Van Klink, D. E. Bowler, K. B. Gongalsky, a. B. Swengel, a. Gentile, J. M. Chase

10.1126/science.abf1915 · 2020

Meta-Analysis Reveals Declines in Terrestrial but Increases in Freshwater Insect Abundances

10.1126/science.aax9931 · 2020

Functional Differences Stabilize Beetle Communities by Weakening Interspecific Temporal Synchrony

10.1002/ecy.2748 · 2019

Insect Decline in the Anthropocene: Death by a Thousand Cuts

10.1073/pnas.2023989118 · 2021

Minimum Time Required to Detect Population Trends: The Need for Long-Term Monitoring Programs

10.1093/biosci/biy144 · 2018

Additional external references

No additional external references are available.

InsectChange: Comment

Referenced works

Cited by

External reference records

Additional external references