Abstract
Nanobubbles (NBs) have been widely investigated as ultrasound contrast and therapeutic agents, yet whether submicron gas bubbles can directly generate measurable ultrasound signals remains controversial. Because acoustic scattering scales with bubble size, several studies have recently attributed nanobubble echogenicity primarily to larger bubbles. A recent Science Advances publication, attributed the loss of ultrasound signal after filtration to the removal of residual larger bubbles [1]. This interpretation assumes that filtration acts solely as a size-selection process. Here, we show that filtration also alters the shell properties and stability of lipid-coated NBs, independent of size. Filtered NBs (F-NBs) show significant lipid loss and accumulation on the filters themselves, resulting in decreased bubble stability and greater susceptibility to destruction under acoustic excitation. To decouple size from processing effects, we generated NB populations size-matched to filtered samples using increased centrifugation (IC-NBs), a comparatively gentler separation method. Despite comparable size distributions, IC-NBs retained sustained ultrasound scattering, whereas filtered NBs showed significantly reduced acoustic persistence. Filtration through 5 μm pores, ~5-fold larger than the largest bubbles, preserved acoustic persistence but still reduced bubble concentration by ~30%, suggesting that membrane contact may contribute to bubble loss beyond size exclusion. Complementary lipid and gas-content assays provided further evidence of filtration-induced changes. The 0.45 μm filtration removed substantially more total lipid than could be attributed to free-lipid removal alone, while the lipid associated with the larger bubbles removed during filtration accounted for only ~5% of the additional lipid loss. Encapsulated gas content remained comparable to that of size-matched centrifuged controls, suggesting that the reduced acoustic stability of filtered NBs is more closely associated with changes in lipid content than with loss of the gas core. These results indicate that membrane filtration is not a purely size-selective process: it removes substantially more lipid than size exclusion predicts and yields bubbles that are less stable under ultrasound, most likely through changes in shell lipid content or in the surrounding lipid reservoir, underscoring the importance of processing-induced effects in interpreting nanobubble echogenicity.